If your foundation and blush set the stage, then your eyes and brows are where the real drama unfolds. The best mascaras, eyeshadows, eyeliners and brow products can truly define the mood and the formality of any look. A smudge of neutral eyeshadow and well-defined brows can add polish to your daily glow, while dark and dramatically lined eyes coupled with long, voluminous lashes can instantly turn any evening into a red carpet moment. Of course, to do this you need all the right products—which is where our 2022 Healthy Beauty Award winners come in.
To arrive at this winning list, we reviewed thousands—and we mean actual thousands—of submitted products. Next, we decided what to test based on guidelines set by dermatologists, and then we enlisted the help of over 50 testers—including SELF editors, makeup pros, new parents, and dermatologists—to try out everything. The products you see below—several of which are drugstore steals—were all tried, tested, and raved about. Check them all out and don’t forget to see our full list of winning items from this year’s SELF Healthy Beauty Awards right here.
Reviews have been edited and condensed for length and clarity.
All products featured on SELF are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.